My Dad is wanting to build a computer to replace his DVD player, CD player and VHS collection. He's asked for my help, and right now I'm looking at two options. One is to go for Windows Media Center Edition, and the other is to go for Debian Linux + MythTV.

What I'm thinking so far is that the Windows solution is slick and integrated, but it would be expensive (both for the software and hardware). My dad is a frugal guy, so I'm not sure I could sell it. The linux solution is free (software) and has flexible hardware requirements. Both are feature-rich. One of many benefits to going for the linux based solution (that I just thought of) is that when I get the inevitable support requests, I can just ssh into the linux box and fix it myself.

Have any of you tried anything similar? Have any suggestions? Leave a comment!